Brexit pros and cons: your guide to leaving the EU
Brexit is the most important and divisive event in British politics in decades. At least it could be. We don’t really know what it means yet. Let alone the outcome. Britain voted to leave the EU. And our government gave the EU formal notice of our intention to leave. But nobody knows where we’re actually going.
What will life be like outside the EU? What will our relationship with Europe look like? How will Gibraltar and Northern Ireland fare? Will Brexit affect Scottish independence? What will change when British politicians are back in charge of Britain?
The fact that we don’t know how things will work out makes it very hard to have an opinion on Brexit. That doesn’t stop anyone from having their opinion though. Let’s steer clear of that sort of pontificating for a moment.
There are some things we do know. And they do give us hints about our future outside the EU. This guide introduces you to the facts, figures and people you need to know to understand Brexit. You’ll find out:
- What does Brexit really mean?
- Who are the lead negotiators of Brexit?
- What is the effect on the economy?
- How will monetary policy change?
- What are the prospects for the pound?
- How will Brexit affect the stock and property markets?
Let’s dig into those questions…
Brexit’s Changes to the Law
Britain has voted to leave the EU. But what does that actually mean? We didn’t really vote for anything. Just against Brussels.
This creates a huge amount of uncertainty. Not just because our trade ties and freedom of movement with Europe are at risk. But because we don’t know what British policies will look like when they replace the EU’s.
A 2010 study by the House of Commons Library estimated between 14% and 17% of our laws come from the EU. Under Brexit, European law will no longer trump British law. We’ll be free to make our own policies. But what will they be? And which areas will they cover?
Control over immigration policies were the key issue of the referendum. Continental Europe is suffering under freedom of movement and an open-door policy for refugees. Brits feel the strain too, although immigration is less of a problem here. Still, we’re likely to sure up our borders and become selective about immigration.
Fisheries and agriculture will come back under our control. British farmers’ EU subsidies will likely be replaced. We’ll introduce new fishing quotas too.
The EU’s overzealous employment law is tangling business in red tape. Just complying is expensive. Under our own sovereignty, Britain could free up employment and generate a huge amount of jobs. Productivity could jump as well.
The enforcement of policing and the structure of our human rights institutions could change too. Currently, Brits must be delivered to foreign courts inside the EU if accused of a crime there. But these courts can severely lack the sort of civil rights supposedly guaranteed under EU law.
Britain could become a centre for technology if it implements the right policies on types of innovation that the EU stifles. The same goes for small business policies and regulation, which are currently a mix of EU and national rules.
But by far the most important part of leaving the EU will be trade. It’s the one area that requires cooperation from Europe. But that cooperation might not be forthcoming. And without decent trade ties our economy could be in trouble.
The Brexit negotiators
To understand the Brexit negotiations with Europe you’ll need to understand who the negotiators are. They might be the key to unlocking how things will unfold.
Eurosceptic campaigners often bring up several poster children as examples of EU failures. What’s remarkable is that the EU has appointed as its lead negotiator for Brexit someone who was in charge of many of those failed policies.
Michel Barnier has had an interesting career to say the least. Having lost the vote on the European Constitution, he became the French agriculture minister, pushed for the creation of a European defence force, rewrote the rejected), European constitution into the Treaty of Lisbon (which his own voters then rejected, went on to regulate the banks at the onset of the European sovereign debt crisis and became the Commissioner for Entrepreneurship in the EU. Barnier typifies the EU’s grand ambitions in the face of repeated rejection.
On the other side of the negotiation table we have someone equally interesting.
Britain’s lead negotiator is David Davis. He claims to have made £1,000 betting on the Brexit referendum. He grew up on a council estate in London. After being disinherited for becoming a Communist, Davis joined the SAS reserve, founded a university radio station and went to Harvard. He was Minister of State for Europe in the 90s, Conservative Party chairman recently and Chairman of the Federation of Conservative Students during his studies. In the first round ballot for Conservative Party leadership, he came first and beat David Cameron. But not in round two.
Now that you know the cast of this unfolding drama, let’s take a look at the plot…
The economic effect of Brexit
It’s important to note when we’re looking at the economy, that Brexit hasn’t happened yet. There has been no change to trade policy or our relationship with the EU. Therefore economic data is more a representation of people’s confidence and outlook.
Of course, before the vote we were told the uncertainty alone would be enough to damage the economy. That hasn’t been the case. In fact, each of these predictions of disaster from credible mainstream professionals and policy-makers was diametrically wrong. The British economy has been doing well on most counts.
We’ll know more about the longer-term outlook for the economy as time goes on. Much of it will depend on the outcome of negotiations. And the policies that Britain pursues in place of EU prescriptions. But in the meantime, the expected knock to growth brought on by uncertainty hasn’t materialised.
Monetary policy and mortgages
The Bank of England responded to Britain’s “Leave” vote in a predictable way. It promised more easy money: lower rates and more money printing (quantitative easing). But then it reversed its decision after criticism from Prime Minister Theresa May and the lack of an economic shock after the vote.
What does this mean for mortgages? At first glance, the lack of monetary policy action might seem bad for mortgage holders. But remember that extreme monetary policy has the potential to get out of hand. A more responsible hand is likely to result in more stable interest rates in the future.
Brexit’s effect on the pound
The pound has been on the sharp end of the Brexit saga. As a highly liquid global market, currencies are the first place to respond to new data, political posturing and legal wrangling over how Britain should leave the EU.
The pound fell to a low of $1.18 against the dollar – suffering a flash crash on the way down – having been at $1.70 a year before.
The pound’s fall has acted as a pressure valve for the effects of Brexit. It boosted our stock and property markets, as you’ll see in a moment.
Recently, central banks in emerging markets revealed they planned to lessen their exposure to the euro and increase their holdings of the pound because of political instability in Europe.
Brexit’s effect on the stock-market
The falling pound was like rocket fuel for the FTSE 100. It soared in the aftermath of the vote, as the pound sank.
These two trends are connected. The FTSE 100 is stuffed full of companies with huge overseas earnings. A falling currency is great news for these firms. If you’re in any doubt of that, just look at the following chart. It shows the pound (blue line) dropping as the FTSE 100 (red line) jumps.
Investment in the UK after Brexit
Britain became the world’s number two destination for foreign investment in 2016 according to the United Nations. While the rest of the world saw a whopping 13% decline, and Europe a 29% decline, British foreign direct investment quintupled.
The low pound probably did some good in attracting new business to the UK. It makes Britain a cost-effective place to do business for foreigners.
Several large deals contributed to the surge. Apple, Google, Amazon and Nissan all announced significant investment in the UK recently. CFOs of local firms are slowly warming to Brexit too, according to quarterly polls.
Property prices after Brexit
The falling pound has also made UK property cheaper for overseas buyers – which is one of the reasons the market has shown strength since the vote.
After falling in July and August, asking prices rose in both September and October. In particular, the market outside of London has performed well.
However, reduced immigration could put the demand for UK property at risk in the long term.
Gibraltar, Northern Ireland and Scotland
Where does Brexit leave Britain’s overseas territories? Some are more connected to the EU than Britain in many ways. And will the Scots demand independence over Brexit?
Hopefully these issues will force leaders to reach decent compromises. People in Gibraltar and Northern Ireland obviously shouldn’t be shut off from Europe. But neither should the heartland of the UK for that matter.
If the EU plays hardball with the UK, it has to justify the terrible effect this would have on Northern Ireland and Gibraltar, which is very hard to do. But making exceptions for them exposes the hypocrisy of a tough deal with Britain – it benefits nobody.
Scottish independence will force British politicians to reach a compromise in much the same way. Without a deal that keeps the Scots happy, they face losing the country.
The consequences of Brexit
Is Brexit a good thing? Only hindsight will tell us. And even then, the answer is unlikely to be clear-cut. But it is clear that you need to understand what’s going on. All the issues outlined above affect you, often directly. You can stay up to date by subscribing to Capital & Conflict and be in the know about Brexit.